|
|
 |
| Article
"The Nation" 6 April-06 |
| |
Pakistan is one of the more than two dozen countries which, according
to the Global Monitoring Report (GMR 2006), will not be able to
achieve any of the targets set at the World Education Forum in 2000.
Pakistan is committed to these targets for 'Education for All' and
as a follow-up of the Dakar Declaration was able to prepare a National
Plan of Action fairly quickly. The implementation of the Plan however
has remained halting and unsatisfactory. The plan, for instance,
envisaged the opening of more than 300,000 literacy centers by now
and about 80,000 non-formal basic education centers for out of school
children. But the actual number of centres on the ground is a fraction
of the targets.
The central government's budgetary allocation for literacy has been
about Rs100 million as against the planned more than Rs10 billion
a year. Yes Punjab and NWFP have taken commendable steps. Punjab
has a full-fledged department of literacy and non-formal basic education
headed by a full-fledged cabinet minister and secretary. And the
NWFP government has set up an autonomous foundation for elementary
education headed by a dynamic chairman with considerable funds provided
for the literacy projects. Both the provinces have launched impressive
programmes for adult literacy and non-formal basic education. But
these efforts even if successfully managed will only make a limited
contribution towards meeting of the huge literacy challenge facing
the country.
The picture in Sindh and Balochistan is quite bleak. Practically,
these two provinces have yet to prepare provincial and district
plans, earmark adequate funds and work for the creation of appropriate
organisational arrangements to start viable literacy programmes.
A ray of hope has come from the National Commission for Human Development
headed by Dr Nasim Ashraf. The Commission has drawn up a national
programme to strengthen the primary schools and establish thousands
of literacy centres all over the country. Has the Commission the
capacity to massively up- scale its operations countrywide and address
the literacy challenge? Will it be able to get the required funds?
Much will depend on the answers to these questions.
With all the rhetoric and tall claims about the need for literacy
and education emanating from the highest levels, the movement towards
the attainment of the goal of a literate Pakistan is painfully slow.
It also needs to be said that the figures given by government about
literacy statistics do not carry much credibility. For quite sometime
the post of the director general of the Federal Statistics Bureau
has been lying vacant. Why this neglect? Is it deliberate as suggested
by some critics? It is suggested that the figures can be engineered
with junior officers in-charge.
Now a look at the government figures. According to the Ministry
of Education as many as six million children are still out of school.
The Punjab education minister says that 53 per cent of children
joining primary school still drop out in the first two years. A
major reason for this wastage is poor quality of teachers and an
unwholesome school environment. More than 52 million Pakistanis
above the age of 10 are totally illiterate. Two thirds of them are
women.
Credit goes to Unesco for keeping literacy centre stage, in its
programmes in Pakistan. But for its spirited support for this cause
governments' record might have been worse. Unesco's latest contribution
is LIFE - Literacy Initiative For Empowerment. 34 countries lagging
behind the rest of the world have been flagged for special help
with funds and technical assistance. Pakistan because of its poor
record has been chosen along with Bangladesh for special treatment.
In December, Unesco Islamabad office held a national consultation
meeting on LIFE in the context of the literacy challenge facing
Pakistan. In a Unesco presentation the issues identified were :a)
insufficient political will b) weak organisational structure. c)
inadequate financing and delay in disbursement . d) low-level of
Capacity. e) low awareness of the importance of literacy. F) lack
of monitoring and evaluation system and g) absence of uniform national
curriculum.
The recommendations proposed were:
i. Enhance political support
ii. Raise financial allocations for education from 2% to 4%
iii. Earmark 5-8% of educational budget for literacy and non-formal
education
iv. Streamline organisational infrastructure for literacy and NFE-
from national level to district level
v. Set up a National Literacy Authority
This curtain raiser meeting on LIFE was followed by a Regional Planning
Workshop in March. It was attended by Unesco experts from Paris,
Tokyo, Hamburg and Bangkok as well as Indonesia, China, India, Bangladesh
and many other countries. These specialists interacted with Pakistani
officials and NGO representatives to evolve a schedule of need assessment
and develop a strategy for revitalising and accelerating the spread
of literacy in Pakistan. The existing programmes and approaches
were reviewed. Recommendations were made for the formation of a
national steering committee which will plan and oversee project
implementation with emphasis on strengthening institutional capacity,
improvement of efficiency of literacy manages and teaches and the
production of need-based reading materials.
Hopefully, the Pakistani government will avail of this opportunity
to gear up its will to build institutional capacity for planning
and implementing literacy programmes. Hopefully the funds to be
provided by Unesco for remedying the flaws and deficiencies in the
present efforts and the offer of technical assistance would not
be frittered away by a listless and myopic approach.. It is not
clear if the top leadership has the requisite commitment to own
the cause of literacy. One may hear recall how the baby was thrown
out with the bath water when the much-needed National Literacy Commission
was abolished on the recommendation of a shortsighted economy committee.
The good news is that the education budget is expected to be raised
from two per cent to four per cent of the GDP. Federal Education
Secretary says that funds would no longer be a problem. This assurance
has yet to be tested as while allocation for education may increase,
the amount provided for literacy may remain inadequate. Equally
important is the making of right policies, programmes and methodologies
as well as a practicable implementation strategy. An essential part
of the strategy will relate to building up of infrastructural and
institutional strength. There is much to learn from the way India
has managed to reach more then 65 per cent literacy rate while Pakistan
sits at the lowest rung of the South Asian literacy ladder.
I close this column with an except from the publication, Literacy--
a Unesco Perspective: "Literacy is more than reading and writing.
It is about how we communicate in society. It is about social practices
and relationships, about knowledge, language and culture. Literacy
contributes to freedom and equity; it is part of any social project,
which aims at a fairer and more just society. Open and democratic
systems of governance require open and adequate communication channels;
no society in today's world can function without the written dimension
of communication- text on paper, on the computer screen, on the
TV, coupled with images and icons of all kinds. Literacy is an inescapable
part of life in today's world. In his book Development as Freedom,
Amartya Sen observes repeatedly that the expansion of literacy,
especially female literacy, has a positive effect on basic aspirations
such as life expectancy and political voice".
E-mail: pacade@brain.net.pk
|
|